11th Nov 2007
Remembrance in 21st century Ireland
I have been impressed again as I am every beginning on November at the depth and relevance of the Festival of Remembrance in Britain. It’s probably the most unifying event of they year embracing the peoples of Scotland, Wales and England but also a very large people on the island of Ireland. It points in the most symbolic way to the shared history of these islands and the cathartic events leading up to and following the First World War. I heard that war described as the great Liberal war during the week. Not because of what they were fighting against (and there is new evidence this week that Germany was already in 1914 determined on the extermination of-the Jewish people) but because it was a war of volunteers and one which was devolved in recruitment terms to local councils, militia groups and even some large companies - the ruling liberal party was against conscription. That certainly explains the way in which Irish men were recruited across the island, leaving catholics on one part of the front and protestants on the other.
In the past decade we have been able to explore the shared aspect of our island’s participation in the First World War more honestly. Even some contemporary republicans have openly spoken about ancestors who fought and died in France. There has also been a proud campaign to restore the dignity of those who found the pressures of the trenches too much and were shot for abandoning their posts. They are victims of that conflict also and are now ninety years on being remembered as such. North and South there has also been a movement to acknowledge the many catholic Irish men who died. It is important to remember that they were doing nothing treacherous by signing up to a war they believed was about defending the freedom of small nations. Two Sunday’s ago at the diamond in Derry one of my best friends, Fearghal O’Boyle,became - as far as I know - the first person to lower the tricolour in front of the war memorial in an act of remembrance. I can’t think of a more proper way of acknowledging these young men’s sacrifice than through the symbolic lowering of their nation’s flag alongside the union flag in a formal act of remembrance. Fearghal is taking our little gang of friends to the battlefields of France early next year. I have been before with him but this time I look forward to the many new stories I know he has picked up through his fine work.
There is no personal story for me at the Somme though. My family came from the ‘other side’ and in 1914 that was not such much a religious statement as a political one. North and South, my parents were born into republican homes where the advent of the First World War was seen as an opportunity for Ireland. In Galway my grandfather was to spend much of the period of the war in jail in England and in Belfast my paternal great grandfather provided refuge for deserting soldiers in the attic of his tailor’s shop on Rosemary Street. They were committed to Irish freedom and were not willing to fight for the empire in any circumstances. They were the minority in 1914 but would soon become involved in the events leading up to Easter 1916 and ultimately partition. The rest is history.
When two cousins of mine, born and bred in England, joined the British Army and served in Northern Ireland during the eighties, the complicated nature of allegiance and honour on these islands was debated long and hard in our family. As it happens when the time came to bury my Grandmother, a wonderful Galway woman who lived well into her nineties, all her 27 grandsons - English and Irish - lined up and shared the load of her coffin on its slow walk to interment beside her beloved, so many years ago a prisoner of our politics.
Then we have modern ‘remembrance’ in Ireland. Twenty years after Enniskillen, and nearly a decade after Omagh we are still struggling about how to remember. It has taken over eighty years for the ‘two’ sides of the first world war in Ireland, combatants and non combatants, to find the space to recognise each other properly. I hope it will not be that long before the two communities in the North find a way of acknowledging and remembering that war at the end of the day, in all its forms, is a story of human tragedy and love lost. Nobody has a monopoly on grief and in these islands nothing is ever quite as simple as it seems. Lets us all remember that.
I have been impressed again as I am every beginning on November at the depth and relevance of the Festival of Remembrance in Britain. It’s probably the most unifying event of they year embracing the peoples of Scotland, Wales and England but also a very large people on the island of Ireland. It points in the most symbolic way to the shared history of these islands and the cathartic events leading up to and following the First World War. I heard that war described as the great Liberal war during the week. Not because of what they were fighting against (and there is new evidence this week that Germany was already in 1914 determined on the extermination of-the Jewish people) but because it was a war of volunteers and one which was devolved in recruitment terms to local councils, militia groups and even some large companies - the ruling liberal party was against conscription. That certainly explains the way in which Irish men were recruited across the island, leaving catholics on one part of the front and protestants on the other.
In the past decade we have been able to explore the shared aspect of our island’s participation in the First World War more honestly. Even some contemporary republicans have openly spoken about ancestors who fought and died in France. There has also been a proud campaign to restore the dignity of those who found the pressures of the trenches too much and were shot for abandoning their posts. They are victims of that conflict also and are now ninety years on being remembered as such. North and South there has also been a movement to acknowledge the many catholic Irish men who died. It is important to remember that they were doing nothing treacherous by signing up to a war they believed was about defending the freedom of small nations. Two Sunday’s ago at the diamond in Derry one of my best friends, Fearghal O’Boyle,became - as far as I know - the first person to lower the tricolour in front of the war memorial in an act of remembrance. I can’t think of a more proper way of acknowledging these young men’s sacrifice than through the symbolic lowering of their nation’s flag alongside the union flag in a formal act of remembrance. Fearghal is taking our little gang of friends to the battlefields of France early next year. I have been before with him but this time I look forward to the many new stories I know he has picked up through his fine work.
There is no personal story for me at the Somme though. My family came from the ‘other side’ and in 1914 that was not such much a religious statement as a political one. North and South, my parents were born into republican homes where the advent of the First World War was seen as an opportunity for Ireland. In Galway my grandfather was to spend much of the period of the war in jail in England and in Belfast my paternal great grandfather provided refuge for deserting soldiers in the attic of his tailor’s shop on Rosemary Street. They were committed to Irish freedom and were not willing to fight for the empire in any circumstances. They were the minority in 1914 but would soon become involved in the events leading up to Easter 1916 and ultimately partition. The rest is history.
When two cousins of mine, born and bred in England, joined the British Army and served in Northern Ireland during the eighties, the complicated nature of allegiance and honour on these islands was debated long and hard in our family. As it happens when the time came to bury my Grandmother, a wonderful Galway woman who lived well into her nineties, all her 27 grandsons - English and Irish - lined up and shared the load of her coffin on its slow walk to interment beside her beloved, so many years ago a prisoner of our politics.
Then we have modern ‘remembrance’ in Ireland. Twenty years after Enniskillen, and nearly a decade after Omagh we are still struggling about how to remember. It has taken over eighty years for the ‘two’ sides of the first world war in Ireland, combatants and non combatants, to find the space to recognise each other properly. I hope it will not be that long before the two communities in the North find a way of acknowledging and remembering that war at the end of the day, in all its forms, is a story of human tragedy and love lost. Nobody has a monopoly on grief and in these islands nothing is ever quite as simple as it seems. Lets us all remember that.
Posted in Personal, Politics | No Comments »
