This is an expanded version of an article I have written for this month’s edition of Fortnight Magazine.
————————————
The SDLP is at a cross roads, there is no doubt about that. Many perceived Good Friday 1998 as the fulfilment of its historic mission, yet there is as great a need for strategic leadership on this island today as at any point in the last century.
The Agreement was a decade ago and in the years since the SDLP can rightly claim to feel more than a little shafted by the British and Irish Governments and damaged by the retirement of the entire leadership in the space of two years. The governments played a dangerous game with the SDLP. The party ‘with no guns’ to quote Tony Blair was served up to Sinn Fein as the prize if they cooperated. That never bothered New Labour – they were never going to face them in an election and whilst Fianna Fail were happy to flirt with SF north of the border they played an opposite game in the South, crucifying Gerry Adams and his fellow travellers at the last election.
This is all for the record. The fact is the SDLP is still at the cross roads and little does it matter now how it got there. What does matter is that politicking and side deals aside, the institutions that are being shared in Northern Ireland are SDLP creations - the product of true vision and persistent argument.
Yes, the SDLP is poorly organised in many parts of the North, many MLAs are due an MoT they may or may not pass, and whilst there are enough young faces competing in the succession stakes, the party gives the appearance of treading water. It’s a pity because there is plenty to oppose: from Catriona Ruane’s gambling with our children’s future to a right wing, pay more get less, budget with SF endorsement and the politicking around victims and parades. Never mind the failure to secure a lower corporation tax for our businesses.
The SDLP review group is meeting against this backdrop. Made up of senior members it has been asked to report back on future options for the party. The group isn’t working in a vacuum; it has an important document which informs its members as they consider the party’s future. ‘A United Ireland and the Agreement’, states clearly that “The SDLP also believes that in the context of unity there would be a realignment of politics, with parties of the left – and right – joining together across the island.”
For as long as I can remember, there has always been a group within the party, who publicly present themselves as FF-SDLP. Based on support for their motions at conference I reckon they make up about 20% of members. You might expect the rest of the party to be a loose coalition of FG-SDLP, Lab-SDLP, Green-SDLP or even PD-SDLP. Not so. Outside the FF group, the vast majority of members consider themselves to be SDLP, full stop. They are progressive people who believe in unity through agreement and reject sectarianism and its political mouthpieces. They are more than just nationalists. They campaign for and believe in equality and social justice. They are social democrats and new Irelanders in the true sense of the word and if recent internal party meetings are anything to go by they are willing to continue fighting for their beliefs and the party they love. Not surprising that they would overwhelmingly adopt a document clearly stating that realignment should take place along ideological lines.
These people are smart and highly political. They are keen to enter discussions with other parties in the South and in the North about the future of this small island. They see much to be done in the North and much that would need to change in the South if their ambition of an agreed Ireland is to be achieved.
So where to now? The SDLP has three options; do nothing, continue alone or lead the way in shaping 21st century Ireland. Options one and two are already off the table, the tide waits for no man and the sea is rising all around the SDLP. Nationalism is moving on from the conflict and progressive unionism in increasingly interested in exploring new relationships. This is something the party itself recognises. Hence the interest in exploring new alliances, both sides of the border, in order to build a new agreed Ireland.
Speaking to Fianna Fail, Labour, Fine Gael, the UUP and others is an important step on this journey. I know very few SDLP people who would be against the idea of discussions in principle. In fact the vast majority of SDLP people I know would be very keen to talk to other parties about how progressive politics can play the lead role on this island. Social Democrats are always interested in power. They are not parties of protest but parties of change. No surprise that the Review Group has been given such clear policy guidance then.
The SDLP is a member of the Party of European Socialists and the Socialist International alongside many of the world’s most successful parties. If the SDLP were ever to give up this membership they would be surrendering the right to call themselves progressives. They would also be handing Sinn Fein the keys to one of the most influential and powerful political groups in the world. For be under no illusion, SF would apply to join the PES and SI the day after the SDLP left. Gerry Adam’s may sully social democracy on the campaign trail but such statements are about as credible as his denials of ever being in the IRA.
All very well I hear you say. With a decreasing vote and poor organisation it is all fairly academic and now is the time for action not long term strategy. In my mind these are compatible courses of action, not mutually exclusive ones. Many who advocate immediate merger with FF come from some of the most poorly organised parts of the SDLP, many more are not even members of the SDLP. Fianna Fail is all about organisation. It could well turn out that those who want change most could well become its first casualties.
It may be that many of the MLAs, have lost the ability to organise and are searching for a quick fix. On the other hand it may be that they realise just how much they still have, the huge job of work that still needs to be done and the need to get on with it. There will be change. However, nobody surrenders an inch with making another one somewhere else. And some things, like social democracy and the ‘New Ireland’ agenda simply cannot be for sale.
There is a big opportunity for progressive politics on this island. In the commercial world brands change but they never give up their core proposition. My own view is that the SDLP’s social democracy and membership of the PES is more attractive to other parties on this island than many in the party recognise. The big future for the party is to realise its ambition for a new Ireland without surrendering the core values that delivered peace to this island.